The Commonwealth of Massachusetts,
Department of Environmental Protection, have allegedly devised more stringent
standards in the treatment of on site wastewater through its Title 5, enacted
in 1995. With most of the clogging effect removed in the wastewater, the MA DEP allow a reduction in the separating distance to groundwater for open bottom chamber, gallery, pipe/stone and other infiltration devices. It appears open bottom Chambers have been approved for use in Massachusetts and other states without testing to evaluate the impact on underlying waters from a device which simply creates a void with open bottom effluent access to underlying soils. Most chamber devices also have perforations on their sides to enhance effluent delivery to surrounding soils. Although these open bottom raw septic effluent delivery devices have been approved without testing, the MA DEP requires testing for the Living Filter even though it actually pre treats the effluent prior to discharge into the underlying soils. The testing would cost approximately $15,000.00 per system for a potential total cost of $500,000.00 to $1,000,000.00 to ascertain that the Living Filter product would provide at least equivalent protection to currently approved systems (conventional pipe and stone trenches, open bottom dumping chambers and galleries, wrapped perforated pipe etc). The Living Filter comprise the following
treatment features between the Septic Tank (Digesting Tank) and underlying
soils: (1) Filter Sand, (2) Reinforced Biological Membrane for mechanical
filtration and biochemical conversion, Now after more than 10 years of operation at a Condominium Site in South Yarmouth, MA these are the actual readings in the mound (groundwater) directly adjacent (5 lf) and downgradient the BIOREN System. These test results have been similar during prior years of testing. Samples were drawn on June 26, 2008 by George Huefelder, RS, Barnstable County Health Dept. Nitrate as Nitrogen - 0.21 mg/l (maximum contaminant level [MCL] is 10 mg/l), Nitrite as Nitrogen - None Detected (ND), Ammonia as Nitrogen - ND, Phosphorous - 0.07 mg/l , Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen (TKN) - 1.3 mg/l, Total Suspended Solids - ND, Fecal Coliform < 10 CFU / 100 ml.
It appears the standard applied by
many agencies like MA DEP relies on the native soil structure and its flora
of bacteria to do the renovation and therefore open bottom devices are acceptable
to their standards. There are claims by one or more manufacturers
that their chamber devices are innovative, technological marvels, while stating
that stone/aggregates do not contribute to the treatment of effluent.
The only apparent innovation may be the multi-angular effluent delivery orifices
present on the sides of some of these devices, which manufacturers propose
prevent the intrusion of soils. There are also writings that chamber
"technology" has been around for twenty-five years. I firmly take exception
to this statement as I personally was involved in the installation of open
bottom dumping chamber devices 33 years ago in East Burke, Vermont.
(***) |